(845) 278-2555
A Delicious rainbow frosted Custom Cake, Custom Orders for Holidays and Occasions from Brewster Pastry

Cakes

Baked in-house daily

Happiness is only a cake away!

Delicious, decadent, and baked to order. Experience the difference in season, old-world style french baking, all done in-house at our Family-owned bakery. Stop in daily to see what delicious fresh-baked cake offerings we have!

Enjoying a slice of chocolate cake, baked fresh in the old-world french style at Brewster Pastry
Custom thanksgiving chocolate cake from Brewster Pastry, with a frosting turkey design

Special Orders from Brewster Pastry

So many styles...
so little time

In the almost two decades that we’ve been open, we have created thousands of delicious cakes, and stock fresh-baked cakes of multiple styles daily in-house at our bakery.

Whether you’re looking for rich chocolate, a strawberry shortcake, sheet cakes, tiramisu or even Gluten-Free, we have something for all flavors and appetites.

Scroll through a sampling of the specialty cake offerings you can find at Brewster Pastry below. See our complete fresh-baked offerings on our Brewster Pastry Menu page, including pastries, breads, pies, tartes and more- availabilities and prices subject to change.

Here’s just a few of the cake styles we offer…

Specialty Cake Menu

See our complete menu of offerings – Please contact us for special orders! Prices subject to change without notice.

The Brewster – Thierry’s Signature Cake
Chocolate cake, Creamy cheesecake with layers of rich ganache, all covered in a smooth ganache icing

Cannoli Cake
Yellow cake layered w/ cannoli cream and covered in whipped cream

Carrot Cake
With walnuts & raisins, a smooth cream cheese icing

Cheesecake
Plain creamy cheesecake

Chocolate Mousse
Chocolate cake layered w/ chocolate mousse; then covered in mousse & glazed

Marjolain
Meringue layers with a layer each of ganache, mocha buttercream covered in toasted almonds

Molly Brown
Chocolate cake with strawberries, bananas & fresh whipped cream

Napoleon
Flaky puff pastry layered with custard & covered with fondant

Rum Cake
Yellow cake with a layer each of chocolate & vanilla custard & rum syrup, covered in toasted almonds

Tiramisu
Yellow cake dipped in espresso w/ imported marscapone cheese & marsala wine, surrounded by dark & white lady fingers

Strawberry Shortcake
Yellow cake layered w/ fresh strawberries & whipped cream

Red Velvet Cake
Authentic red velvet coke filled & covered with smooth cream cheese icing

Shadow Cake
Yellow and chocolate cake layered with white and chocolate buttercream

Lemon Cake
Yellow cake filled with golden lemon covered with white

Sprinkle Cake
Yellow cake layered with white buttercream and surntiestosered with white buttercream and sprinkles

The Brewster – Thierry’s Signature Cake
Chocolate cake, Creamy cheesecake with layers of rich ganache, all covered in a smooth ganache icing

Cannoli Cake
Yellow cake layered w/ cannoli cream and covered in whipped cream

Carrot Cake
With walnuts & raisins, a smooth cream cheese icing

Cheesecake
Plain creamy cheesecake

Chocolate Mousse
Chocolate cake layered w/ chocolate mousse; then covered in mousse & glazed

Marjolain
Meringue layers with a layer each of ganache, mocha buttercream covered in toasted almonds

Molly Brown
Chocolate cake with strawberries, bananas & fresh whipped cream

Napoleon
Flaky puff pastry layered with custard & covered with fondant

Rum Cake
Yellow cake with a layer each of chocolate & vanilla custard & rum syrup, covered in toasted almonds

Tiramisu
Yellow cake dipped in espresso w/ imported marscapone cheese & marsala wine, surrounded by dark & white lady fingers

Strawberry Shortcake
Yellow cake layered w/ fresh strawberries & whipped cream

Red Velvet Cake
Authentic red velvet coke filled & covered with smooth cream cheese icing

Shadow Cake
Yellow and chocolate cake layered with white and chocolate buttercream

Lemon Cake
Yellow cake filled with golden lemon covered with white

Sprinkle Cake
Yellow cake layered with white buttercream and surntiestosered with white buttercream and sprinkles

See some Cake Photos

Gallery

Here’s a small sampling of the cakes and custom cake orders we offer. Looking for something specific? We can customize any delicious treat to fit the theme and dietary restrictions of your holidays and occasions. See more photos on our Instagram Page, and Contact our experienced bakers today to see what we can do for you! 

Celebrate Holiday and Occasions

Custom Cake Orders from Brewster Pastry

Are you looking for a custom cake for your event or special occasion? Let our experienced bakery team create a delicious, unforgettable cake that will be the centerpiece of so many unforgettable memories. 

Click the button below to get started!

Custom Birthday Cake with strawberry frosting baked to order in the old world french style at brewster pastry

Customer Testimonials

"I just had their FRESH Peach cake And it was truly Fresh Which means fresh peaches during peach season…, not Too sweet… it was moist and really delish. Anything I have gotten from here has been delicious. Also the service has always been helpful, friendly, attentive and generous 👍"
Amy Bloomberg
"BEST AUTHENTIC FRENCH PASTRIES EVERRR!!!! This pastry is legendary; the croissants are top tier, the cookies are to die for, and the cakes are something to write home about. I've been coming here for a while to satisfy my pastry cravings, and I couldn't ask for anything more. Thank you to the Danvin Family for creating such an authentic french bakery, with such a diverse selection of pastries, cakes, cookies, breads, and other goods."
Lucas Hughes
"I ordered a Napoleon cake that the owner made for my mother-in-law’s 80th birthday and it was out of this world! It was the best Napoleon I’ve ever had. Their rainbow cookies and linzer tarts were amazing too! I love this place!"
Linda Ward

Read more reviews and leave your own review for us on Google!

Hungry?

With so many delicious treats baked in-house fresh daily, the hardest part will be choosing what to eat first. Call us today to see what’s in stock, create a custom order, or just to say hi!