Cookies
Store-Made Cookies at Brewster Pastry
Indulge in Sweet Moments: Explore Our Wonderland of cookies
Welcome to our cookie wonderland at Brewster Pastry, where every bite is a journey into sweet indulgence! Our bakery in Brewster, NY offers a delightful assortment of cookies, meticulously crafted to satisfy every craving and occasion.
From classic favorites to unique creations, our cookie offerings span a wide array of flavors and textures, ensuring there’s something for everyone to enjoy. Sink your teeth into the buttery goodness of our traditional butter cookies, perfectly paired with a cup of coffee or tea for a comforting treat.
But that’s just the beginning – our cookie selection includes an array of flavors, from rich chocolate chip to zesty lemon to delicate almond. Whether you’re looking for a simple snack or a luxurious dessert, our cookies are sure to hit the spot.


Special Orders from Brewster Pastry
Bite into Perfection: All Cookies Baked Fresh Daily!
And with our flexible ordering options, it’s easier than ever to enjoy our cookies anytime, anywhere. Whether you prefer to indulge individually, share by the box, or impress with a beautifully arranged tray or platter, we’ve got you covered.
Treat yourself or someone special to the joy of our delectable cookies at Brewster Pastry. Here’s just a few styles we offer…
- Butter Cookies
- Rainbow Cookies
- Seasonal Favorites
- Lace Cookies
- Lemon Sable
- Linzere Cookies
- Marble Cookies
- Sesame Short Dough Cookies
- Thumb Print Cookies
See some Cake Photos
Gallery
Here’s a small sampling of the cakes and custom cake orders we offer. Looking for something specific? We can customize any delicious treat to fit the theme and dietary restrictions of your holidays and occasions. See more photos on our Instagram Page, and Contact our experienced bakers today to see what we can do for you!
The perfect treat for any Occasion
Custom Order Cookies from Brewster Pastry
At Brewster Pastry, we understand the importance of adding a personal touch to your gatherings and holidays. That’s why we offer custom cookie orders tailored to fit any size celebration or event. Whether you’re hosting an intimate family gathering or a grand holiday soirée, our team is dedicated to creating the perfect selection of cookies to complement your occasion. From themed designs to personalized flavors, we work closely with you to bring your vision to life and ensure your event is as memorable as it is delicious. Let us elevate your next gathering with our custom cookie creations, crafted with care and baked with love.
Click the button below to get started!

Hungry?
With so many delicious treats baked in-house fresh daily, the hardest part will be choosing what to eat first. Call us today to see what’s in stock, create a custom order, or just to say hi!