(845) 278-2555

Pies and Tartes

Brewster Pastry Bakery Menu of Pies and Tartes

Pies and Tartes, made fresh daily the old-world way!

Indulge in a tantalizing array of pies and tartes at Brewster Pastry, where every slice is a delightful journey into French culinary excellence. Picture this: pies, those delectable treats wrapped in flaky crusts and bursting with sweet or savory fillings that warm your soul with every bite. And then there are tartes, the elegant cousins of pies, with their thin, buttery crusts cradling a symphony of vibrant fruits or rich custards, offering a taste of pure sophistication.

At Brewster Pastry, we take pride in crafting these culinary treasures with only the finest and freshest ingredients, ensuring each creation is a masterpiece of flavor and texture. 

A decadent Cherry Danish pastries baked fresh daily with french skill and style at Brewster Pastry

Special Orders from Brewster Pastry

So many styles...
so little time

Whether you’re craving the classic comfort of an apple pie, the indulgent richness of a chocolate tarte, or the tangy brightness of a lemon tarte, our offerings are sure to satisfy every palate. Here’s just a few of the styles we create regularly- Stop in to see what’s available, made fresh daily, or to request a custom order!

  • Pumpkin Pie
  • Apple Pie
  • Apple Crumb Pie
  • Cherry Pie
  • Cherry Crumb Pie
  • Blueberry Pie
  • Blueberry Crumb Pie
  • Apple Cranberry Pie
  • Strawberry Rhubarb
  • Peach Blueberry Rustica
  • Apple Rustica
  • Peach Pie
  • Peach Crumb Pie
  • French Apricot Tarte
  • Pear Tarte
  • Banana Crème Pie
  • Chocolate Crème Pie
  • Lemon Meringue Pie
  • Coconut Custard Pie
  • Bourbon Pecan Pie
  • Fresh Fruit Tarte
  • …and more!

See Pie & Tarte Photos

Gallery

Here’s a small sampling of the pies and tartes we offer. Looking for something specific? We can customize any delicious treat to fit the theme and dietary restrictions of your holidays and occasions. See more photos on our Instagram Page, and Contact our experienced bakers today to see what we can do for you! 

Creating delicious Custom Treats

Custom Pie and Tarte Orders from Brewster Pastry

But why stop there? With custom orders available, you can elevate your dessert experience to new heights, tailor-made to your preferences and occasion. So come on down to Brewster Pastry and treat yourself to a slice of pie or tarte perfection – you deserve it!

Click the button below to get started!

Customer Testimonials

"I just had their FRESH Peach cake And it was truly Fresh Which means fresh peaches during peach season…, not Too sweet… it was moist and really delish. Anything I have gotten from here has been delicious. Also the service has always been helpful, friendly, attentive and generous 👍"
Amy Bloomberg
BEST AUTHENTIC FRENCH PASTRIES EVERRR!!!! This pastry is legendary; the croissants are top tier, the cookies are to die for, and the cakes are something to write home about. I've been coming here for a while to satisfy my pastry cravings, and I couldn't ask for anything more. Thank you to the Danvin Family for creating such an authentic french bakery, with such a diverse selection of pastries, cakes, cookies, breads, and other goods.
Lucas Hughes
I ordered a Napoleon cake that the owner made for my mother-in-law’s 80th birthday and it was out of this world! It was the best Napoleon I’ve ever had. Their rainbow cookies and linzer tarts were amazing too! I love this place!
Linda Ward

Read more reviews and leave your own review for us on Google!

Hungry?

With so many delicious treats baked in-house fresh daily, the hardest part will be choosing what to eat first. Call us today to see what’s in stock, create a custom order, or just to say hi!