Custom Cakes for all Holidays and Occasions

Special Orders from Brewster Pastry
Delicious Custom-Made Cakes, Treats and more For Your Holidays and Occasions
Indulge in a symphony of flavors at your next event, gathering or holiday with our exquisite selection of pastries, pies, tartes, cakes, bread, and cookies– all available in custom order!
All of our custom order delicacies are crafted with the finest ingredients and a dedication to preserving the timeless traditions of French baking. Our experienced baking staff will work directly with you to help you find the perfect, delicious complement to any occasion- baked fresh just for you and your guests- including Gluten-Free cake options!
Call us today to discuss and start your order- (845) 278-2555
Here are just a few of the Holidays and Occasions our experienced bakers have created custom orders for:
- Special Events
- Holidays
- Easter
- Birthdays
- Private Parties
- Graduations
- Sweet 16 Parties
- Christmas Dinner
- Thanksgiving
- Corporate Events
- Anniversaries
- Bar and Bat Mitzvah’s
- Family and Professional Reunions
- School Events for all ages
- Day Camp Events
- Block Parties
- Galas and Balls
- University Functions
- New Years Parties
- Community Events
- Church Groups
- Charity Fundraisers
- Weddings

See some Custom Order Photos
Gallery
Here’s a small sampling of the custom cakes, pastries, breads and orders we offer. We can customize any delicious treat to fit the theme and dietary restrictions of your holidays and occasions. See more photos on our Instagram Page, and Contact our experienced bakers today to see what we can do for you!
Frequently Asked Questions
I want to come visit your bakery! Where are you located?
We are located at 1620 NY-22, #18, in Brewster, NY, located in the Towne Centre plaza in Brewster.
You can also find us at several local farmers markets- see our upcoming events page to see where we will be next!
Is your bakery Kosher?
No, we are not certified Kosher.
Do you partner with other brands and companies?
Of course we do! For any partnership or collaborations, please reach out via phone at (845) 278-2555 or stop in to talk to one of our bakers!
I have a food allergy- can I still eat at your Bakery?
None of our baking is done in an allergen-free environment.
While we can create custom orders of select products that do not contain wheat, dairy or nuts, all of our products are baked in an environment where wheat, milk, peanuts, tree nuts, eggs and soy may be present in high volumes.
Due to the presence of these allergens at all of our baking facilities, we do not recommend consuming any of our desserts if you are allergic to wheat, nuts, dairy or eggs.
Do you offer shipping?
No, we do not offer shipping. All of our orders can be picked up at our Brewster, NY location currently.
Do you do custom orders?
Whether you’re celebrating a wedding, birthday, corporate event, religious holiday, or any other special event- our experienced bakery team will work closely with you to create custom cakes, cupcakes, party favors, dessert tables and more for any occasion.
Please call or stop in to reach out to our team and see what we can do for you!
Are you hiring?
We’re always looking for amazing talent to join our team in a variety of roles. Stop in to talk to one of our staff today to see what positions are available!
Can you tell me more about your ingredients?
We take pride in using only the finest ingredients in our bakery offerings, which can include Callebaut and Hershey chocolate, as well as Philadelphia cream cheese.
We try to source locally whenever possible (including Croton Farms and Ace Endico for dairy products).
All of our bakery products are made from scratch in-house and ingredients can vary by product and supplier. More information can be found by calling or speaking with a member of our staff.
When you’re in our bakery next, a member of our team will be happy to assist you.
Do you have any products that are Vegan?
Our selection of pastries, breads and fresh-baked goods offerings changes daily- but regularly baked breads (Cranberry walnut raisin, olive, roasted garlic, white bread) and bagels are vegan.
To see what’s out available, please call or stop into our store.
Do you have any products that are Gluten-free?
We do carry a select variety of fresh-baked, gluten-free options daily, including our Marjolain (nut meringue layered with chocolate ganache, whipped cream, mocha butter cream, and covered in toasted almonds) and GF chocolate cake (covered in chocolate ganache glaze). Both of those options are available in individual or 7” cake size.
To see what’s available, please call or stop into our store.
If you’d like to place a custom gluten-free order (or an order for any other dietary restriction), please speak to one of our bakers and we will do our best to accommodate your request!
Can I order ahead to have an order ready for pickup?
Of course! We offer advanced local pick-up from our Brewster, NY location. You can plan ahead and place an order in advance via phone. We do not accept local delivery orders via our online advance ordering.
How do I properly transport and store my product/order from your store?
It is extremely important that you take extra caution when transporting cakes or delicate items! All of our product should be kept as flat as possible when transporting. If it is a shelf-stable item, it can be kept at room temperature but we suggest that our product be consumed within 24 hours of purchase to ensure you are getting the best quality. Any items that were refrigerated in our store should be refrigerated when you get to your destination, unless you will be consuming it within a couple of hours. All products should be displayed in cool area away from direct heat or sunlight.
Cakes should be held from the bottom and not by the sides of the box. They should be placed carefully on the passenger side floor of your car, or in the trunk of an SUV or hatchback, not the trunk of a sedan. Seats of cars are slanted and could potentially damage a cake. The car should be at a cool temperature. If it is hot outside, your car should have the a/c on high and if it is cold outside, the heat should be turned off for the entire time of travel. Cakes should be kept out of direct heat or sunlight for extended periods of time. If you will be serving your cake within a 3-hour window, we suggest that you leave it in a cool place to be displayed until the time of serving. If you will not be serving it for well over 3 hours, we suggest that you refrigerate it when you arrive at your destination.
Please drive cautiously and avoid braking too quickly or making sharp turns. We do our best to securely box your order for the easiest transport however some cakes, based on height and shape, cannot be fully covered. We always make sure we are supplying you with a cold and sturdy cake and will do our best to help you get it securely in your vehicle but once the cake leaves our store, we are no longer responsible for it. To avoid any preventable mishaps please make yourself aware of these guidelines, listen to our staff when they explain the best way to transport your specific order, and ask questions if you are unsure of anything!
Order Now!
We take immense pride in delivering the epitome of “Best in Old World Baking.” Our experienced, knowledgeable baking staff are here to assist you. Call today to create your custom cake, cookie or pastry order!
(845) 278-2555
